How to Disclose Conflicts of Interest in Research
A conflict of interest exists when a relationship or interest could be perceived to influence, or actually influences, the design, conduct, analysis or reporting of research. Disclosure lets readers judge for themselves; it is expected of authors, reviewers and editors.
What to disclose
- Financial: grants, consulting fees, speaker fees, employment, stock or patents related to the topic or companies involved, and sponsor support.
- Non-financial: personal, professional or intellectual relationships or strongly held beliefs that might be seen to affect the work.
- Funding and role of funder: who paid for the study and whether they had any role in design, analysis or writing.
How to do it
- Read the journal's instructions and, if required, complete the ICMJE Disclosure of Interest form (check the current form for time windows and categories).
- Each author completes their own form or statement.
- Summarise disclosures in the manuscript (usually a "Conflicts of interest" or "Competing interests" statement).
- If there is no conflict, say so explicitly ("The authors declare no conflicts of interest").
- Update the disclosure if circumstances change before publication.
Why it matters
Undisclosed interests can damage trust and lead to corrections or retraction. Having an interest is not misconduct; hiding it is a problem.
Illustrative example
Invented for teaching. An author received consulting fees from the manufacturer of the drug being studied. The manuscript states the fees, the manufacturer's non-involvement in analysis (if true) and the funding source. Editors and readers can then consider the potential influence.
Common pitfalls
- Thinking that small or past relationships are irrelevant.
- Forgetting that co-authors must disclose too.
Key takeaways
- When in doubt, disclose.
- Be complete, specific and consistent across forms and manuscript.
References and further reading
Related reading
This page is general educational information about research methods. It is not medical, legal or regulatory advice; follow your institution's ethics board and your target journal's instructions.
